Cillian Murphy

Pádraic Delaney

Liam Cunningham

Orla Fitzgerald

Mary O'Riordan

Mary Murphy

Laurence Barry

Damien Kearney

Frank Bourke

Myles Horgan

Martin Lucey

Aidan O'Hare

Shane Casey

John Crean

Máirtín de Cógáin

Keith Dunphy

Kieran Hegarty

Gerard Kearney

Shane Nott

Kevin O'Brien

Gary McCarthy

Tim O'Mahon

Graham Browne

Owen Buckley

Aidan Fitzpatrick

Vince Hannington

Denis Kelleher

Colin McClery

Finbar O'Mahon

John Quinlan

Peggy Lynch

Noel O'Donovan

Peter O'Mahoney

Barry Bourke

Frank O'Sullivan

Diarmuid Ó'Dálaigh

Corina Gough

Roger Allam

Sabrina Barry

William Ruane

Danny Riordan

Peg Crowley

Fiona Lawton

Kieran Aherne

Clare Dineen

Sean McGinley

Tomas OhEalaithe

Nora Lynch

Diarmuid Ní Mheachair

Denis Conway

Barry L. Looney

Connie O'Connail

Aine O'Connor

Francis O'Connor

Peadr O'Riada

Neil Brand

Tom Charnock

Alan Ready

Mark Wakeling

Antony Byrne

Anthony Mark Streeter

Bill Armstrong

Christopher Bown

Mark Bryce

Alex Dee

Jonny Holmes

Allan Huntley

Bill Hurst

Daniel Kington

Jamie Lomas

Anthony Martin

Owen McQuade

Richard Oldham

Colin Parry

Scott Peden

Bernie Sweeney

Derek Taylor

Neil Alan Taylor

Gregor Wood

Karl Dawson

Niall McCarthy

Siobhán McSweeney

Seamus Moynihan

Ken Loach

Paul Laverty

Rebecca O'Brien

George Fenton

Barry Ackroyd

Jonathan Morris

Michael Higgins

Andrew Lowe

Ed Guiney

Gerardo Herrero

Ben Brazier

Julie Ankerson

John Hayward

Kevin Brazier

Ray Beckett

Robert Brazier

Susanna Lenton

Joss Barratt

Carol Moorhead

Fergus Clegg

Patricia Kirkman

Drama

The Wind That Shakes the Barley

Sixteen Films

Matador Pictures

Regent Capital

Element Pictures

BIM Produzione

Tornasol Media

Filmstiftung Nordrhein-Westfalen

Pathe

Germany

Ireland

Italy

Spain

United Kingdom

English

Gaeilge

Latin

guerrilla warfare

civil war

sibling relationship

england

underground

resistance

peace

independence

traitor

mercenary

british army

british empire

dublin, ireland

irish civil war (1922-23)

historical fiction

ira (irish republican army)

ireland

colonialism

irish history

irish

Andres Gomez

Intense drama about Ireland's independence from the UK and the ultimate reasons for the need of freedom.

After watching The Wind That Shakes the Barley, I'm tempted to say that Hollywood ruined Cillian Murphy, but the fact is that this drama written by Paul Laverty and directed by Ken Loach doesn’t really establish, for better or worse, a before and after in the career of the Irish actor; it's more a case of a blind squirrel finding a nut — which is still one more nut than most find (plus, Murphy's range is undeniable, being able to convincingly convey both the most abject cowardice and the most selfless heroism, even within the same film, as he does A Quiet Place Part II).

The Irish Republican Army (IRA) is a group whose main characteristic is separation, especially from itself; Loach deals with the original breakup, resulting in the first two iterations the IRA, drawing a parallel with the story of two brothers who feel compelled to put ideology before family because each is convinced they bleed greener than the other.

It is said that history repeats itself; first as a tragedy, then as a farce. TWTStB follows this pattern, except that in the end the farce ends up being even more tragic than the tragedy. The first half of the film takes place during the Irish War of Independence, a guerrilla war waged between 1919 and 1921 between the IRA and the British occupation forces in Ireland (which included Irish Unionists and Protestants, in contrast to Catholic Republicans).

The second part takes place during the Irish Civil War (1922-1923) which immediately followed the Anglo-Irish Treaty which resulted in the creation of the Irish Free State. Many of those who fought on both sides of the conflict had been members of the IRA during the War of Independence. The bitter irony is that an English character more or less foretells this when he says: "God save Ireland if ever the [Irish republicans] take control."

I'm making it sound like a history class, but TWTStB is far from it; indeed, there is a lesson here, but it is a timeless and universal moral about the fratricidal nature of all wars. Loach and Laverty make their protagonists, Damien (Murphy) and Teddy O'Donovan (Pádraic Delaney) biological brothers to emphasize that all men — Irish and Irish, or even, why not, Irish and English — are brothers and, as As Donne said, "the death of any man diminishes me" because "no man is an island."

Now, just because their characters are symbolic archetypes doesn't mean that Murphy and Delaney just stand there holding signs that say "Cain" and "Abel"; the former in particular turns in a performance in which we can find shades of Peter O'Toole in Lawrence of Arabia.

CinemaSerf

Though quite provocative, I was really disappointed with the anti-British simplicity of this drama. It all centres around two brothers - "Teddy" (Pádraic Delaney) and "Damien" (Cillian Murphy) and the increasingly desperate - and violent - tactics they employed to eject the occupiers from their country. The latter man is not an instant convert to these activities. About to travel to the UK to be a doctor, it's the thuggish squaddies' brutality that convinces him to stay and join his local IRA branch to fight fire with fire. His war-weary brother, on the other hand, is gradually appreciating the stale-mate nature of the predicament and when a settlement is reached between Dublin and London for the "Irish Free State" we find that these siblings are no longer quite on the same side and the conflict turns in on itself. It's not that the British behaved well here, they certainly did not - but the film lacks a key British character to put forward their position. The odious position of Empire, sure, but what, also, of the aspirations of those of a great many Unionists who wanted the status quo and who wanted no truck with the (socialist) republicanism being proposed by "Damien" et al. Again, you can see so much of director Ken Loach's own political persuasion here that he makes no attempt to balance or explain the position from the opposing side, and after a while I found it became a bit of a pontificating rant of a film that illustrated well that expression about one man's terrorist being another's freedom fighter. The then all powerful Catholic church has virtually no role at all here. It's beautifully shot and there are plenty of solid and characterful supporting roles, but no - it could have been better had the director been more interested in offering us more of a objective history rather than his own version of history.

The Wind That Shakes The Barley (2006) Trailer

The Wind That Shakes the Barley( 2006)

War has cost them their innocence... Freedom will cost them their blood.

Overview

Top Billed Cast

Social

A review by Andres Gomez

Written by Andres Gomez on Fri Sep 27 2013

Media

Recommendations

Facts

Status

Original Language

Budget

Revenue

Keywords