Top Billed Cast

1. 

   Ben Stiller

   Mike Maxwell

2. 

   Linda Cardellini

   Gretchen Rice

3. 

   Homer Janson

   Justice Kicklighter

4. 

   Ulysses Janson

   Junior Kicklighter

5. 

   Arlo Janson

   Simon Kicklighter

6. 

   Atlas Janson

   Samuel Kicklighter

7. 

   Toby Huss

   Al Wilmington

8. 

   Maren Heisler

   Mia

9. 

   Edi Patterson

   Rose

10. 

    Tim Heidecker

    Deputy Cox

11. 

    Ari Graynor

    Carol (voice)

12. 

    Ashley Rae Spillers

    Barbara (voice)

13. 

    Lucy Zukaitis

    Julia

14. 

    Bryant Carroll

    Security Guard

15. 

    Louis Heisler

    Anthony Biniak

16. 

    Noah Fisher

    Gus

17. 

    Isabella Steele

    Mia’s Friend

18. 

    Dominick Marrone

    Reverend Logan

19. 

    Vasily Deris

    Theater Manager

20. 

    Jerome Agean

    Radio Announcer

21. 

    Estelle Lapina

    Prop Kid #1

22. 

    Brooks Roseberry

    Prop Kid #2

23. 

    Will Daly

    Prop Kid #3

24. 

    Evan Bartos

    Prop Kid #4

25. 

    Alexander Louis

    Gingerbread Man

26. 

    Rodrigo Almarales

    Gingerbread Man Dancer

27. 

    Jeff Janson

    Steve Kicklighter

28. 

    Melissa Gelfin

    Janet Kicklighter

29. 

    Jenny McManus

    Party Guest (uncredited)