Top Billed Cast

1. 

   Peter Paige

   Paul Johnson

2. 

   Kathy Najimy

   Maggie Butler

3. 

   Anthony Clark

   Russell Trotter

4. 

   Lisa Edelstein

   Sarah Faber

5. 

   Jim Ortlieb

   David Berman

6. 

   Gabrielle Union

   Elise Carter

7. 

   Melanie Lynskey

   Susan

8. 

   Katie O’Grady

   Mother #1

9. 

   Ayanna Berkshire

   Mother #2

10. 

    Don Adler

    Grant Sweet

11. 

    Robert Blanche

    Phil

12. 

    Betty Boyer

    Clothing Store Lady

13. 

    Patrick Dizney

    Jim Faber

14. 

    Heidi Herschbach

    Perky Receptionist

15. 

    Beth Harper

    Adoption Agency Lady

16. 

    Joshua Westhaver

    Crunchy Man

17. 

    Leslie Taylor

    Screaming Mom

18. 

    Kevin Jones

    Simon's Dad

19. 

    Marc Anthony Samuel

    Keith

20. 

    Don Burns

    Richard Long

21. 

    Lori Ferraro

    Coffee Shop Clerk

22. 

    Torrey Cornwell

    Lesbian Mom

23. 

    Victor Morris

    Police Sergeant

24. 

    Ellen Bloodworth

    Donut Shop Woman

25. 

    Brian Pope

    Joey's Dad

26. 

    Maia McCarthy

    Young Mother

27. 

    Brooke Blanchard

    Leslie

28. 

    Brooks McCauley

    Tyler

29. 

    Nina Hambleton

    Lindsay

30. 

    Raymond Burney

    Simon

31. 

    Joshua Pope

    Joey

32. 

    Alexandra Morrison

    Six-Year-Old Girl

33. 

    Jacob Reznicki

    Jacob

34. 

    Madeline Dean

    Ashley

35. 

    Sophie Schoenfeld

    Kid #1

36. 

    Tanner Phelps

    Timmy