Top Billed Cast

1. 

   Mel Gibson

   Gene Carruthers

2. 

   Mason Thames

   Noah Reed

3. 

   Julian Lerner

   Eugene Wexler

4. 

   Abigail James Witherspoon

   Sammy Devers

5. 

   Noah Cottrell

   Ben Driskel

6. 

   Nora Zehetner

   Abby Reed

7. 

   Lorraine Bracco

   Miss Halverson

8. 

   Emma Fasano

   Lilly Reed

9. 

   Spencer Fitzgerald

   Ronnie Harlow

10. 

    Patrick Renna

    Umpire

11. 

    Ashley Rae Trisler

    Witch

12. 

    Gavin Bedell

    Kevin Lampkey

13. 

    Gary Weeks

    Chief Hartley

14. 

    Bobbi Baker

    Hannah Driskel

15. 

    Kelly Collins Lintz

    Deb Harlow

16. 

    Nico Tirozzi

    Little Boy / Carruthers' Son

17. 

    Lilah Pate

    Ellie Evans

18. 

    Kevin James

    Edgar Palmer

19. 

    Barbara Goodson

    The Witch (voice)

20. 

    Abrielle Josephine Cincotti

    Emily

21. 

    Nick Benas

    Baseball Fan (uncredited)

22. 

    Parker E. Chick

    Town Kid (uncredited)

23. 

    Sara Elizabeth Ezzell

    Diner Patron / Pedestrian (uncredited)

24. 

    Robert Fortunato

    Police Officer (uncredited)

25. 

    Keeley Kollmann

    Mom with Kids (uncredited)

26. 

    Samantha Miro

    Jogger (uncredited)

27. 

    Art Newkirk

    Dad in Theater (uncredited)

28. 

    Logan Newkirk

    Book Signing Kid (uncredited)

29. 

    Violet Berlus

    Skip-It Girl

30. 

    Lara Fontes

    Lilly (voice)

31. 

    Derrick Lemmon

    TV News Reporter

32. 

    Hannah Michelle

    Pedestrian

33. 

    Mary Clare Mitchell

    Diner Patron

34. 

    Lucretia Newkirk

    Tourist

35. 

    David Pascua

    Police Officer

36. 

    Veronica Russell

    Baseball Spectator

37. 

    Stacey Stewart

    Carruthers' Wife

38. 

    James Richard Wemmitt

    Camera Man